Best Disney World Resorts Hotels

Best Disney World Deluxe Resort Hotel

by josh on June 3, 2010

Best Disney World Deluxe Resort Hotel

Quick Introduction to the Disney World Deluxe Resorts

Of the three Disney World resort classes, selecting the right Deluxe is the toughest choice.  Unlike the Values and the Moderates, the Deluxes have wildly different price points, ranging from $240 per night to $410 per night, and that’s just for Standard rooms in Value season.  Some Deluxes have as many as 20 different room categories with prices that top $2,000 per night.  Room sizes are also vastly different, ranging in size from about 340 square feet all the way up to 440 square feet for Standard rooms.  While 100 square feet may not seem significant on paper, in person it may seem like you’re adding an additional planet if your group consists of four or five people.  In addition, there are significant differences in resort layout, dining choices, transportation options, theme, service, location, pool size, and more.  I have ranked the Deluxe resorts in a number of categories to help you decide which resort is the best fit for your group.  Don’t be alarmed if your final choice is rated on the lower end of any of the categories because there is no such thing as “one size fits all.”

Also, be sure to read the full length reviews of the resorts you are interested in to get a better idea of what they offer as well as a list of the best rooms.  You can either click the highlighted links throughout this post or click here for a scrollable page with all of the resorts listed alphabetically.

Best Theme/Landscaping

1. Polynesian Resort

2. Animal Kingdom Lodge

3. Wilderness Lodge

4. Grand Floridian

5. Beach Club Resort

6. Boardwalk Inn

7. Yacht Club Resort

8. Contemporary Resort

Save for perhaps the Contemporary, all of the Disney Deluxe resorts have lush surroundings and immersive themes.  I have the Polynesian in first place because of the beautiful grounds, impressive Great Ceremonial House, perfectly-themed volcano pool, and lake-side white sand beaches overlooking Seven Seas Lagoon and the Magic Kingdom.  The Polynesian is one of the most relaxing, pristine resorts at Disney World.  The Animal Kingdom is in second place, but could just as easily take first depending on your own preferences.  Surrounded by 43 acres of African savanna and featuring the most remarkable lobby of any of the Disney Deluxes, the Animal Kingdom is a striking resort and the favorite of many guests.  Few other resorts in the world can boast panoramic views of 30 specifies of indigenous African wildlife and more than 35,000 native shrubs.  It’s an amazing place and an experience every Disney guest should take advantage of, even if you decide to stay elsewhere.

The Wilderness Lodge is a gorgeous, casual resort with a Pacific Northwest flavor.  It shares the beautiful Seven Seas Lagoon with the Deluxe Monorail resorts and has the feeling of being removed from the ruckus of Disney World while still being right in the middle of the action.  The Grand Floridian, Disney’s Flagship Resort, is decidedly “uppity,” yet accommodating and friendly with beautiful architecture, white sand beaches, and a Victorian themed lobby.  Guests looking for upscale surroundings (and price point) should strongly consider it.  The Beach Club Resort is the most friendly and relaxing of the Epcot-area resorts, offering a cool New England seaside vibe and a soft, welcoming color palette.  The Beach Club is the favored Epcot resort for families.  The Boardwalk Inn, themed like an elegant 1940s Atlantic City resort, features an impressive façade and an inviting lobby.  It drops substantially on the list of best themes because the resort itself doesn’t necessarily leave guests exclaiming “Wow.”  Its location right along the Boardwalk is definitely something special, but the resort itself isn’t as extravagantly themed as other Deluxes.

Coming in next to last is the Yacht Club, which isn’t necessarily an indication of an extremely lacking theme.  The Yacht Club is still a solid “B to B+” on a graded scale, but falls to seventh due to its somewhat pretentious tone that doesn’t appeal to some guests.  Anyone looking for a classier, upscale resort should consider the Yacht Club along with the Grand Floridian, but many families report feeling a bit unwelcome at the Yacht Club.  While I’ve never felt that way about the Yacht Club personally, it’s difficult to ignore the feelings of so many past guests.  The only Deluxe with a disappointing theme is the Contemporary Resort, which doesn’t boast much decoration at all.  While the structure itself is a technical feat on a grand scale, most guests won’t appreciate the bland, concrete architecture.  The inside of the resort is void of most things Disney and the industrial atmosphere seems out of place in Disney World.  On the plus side, the lake and Magic Kingdom views from the Tower rooms are spectacular.

Overall, the Disney Deluxe resorts are extravagantly and diversely themed.  It’s likely that more than one of the resorts will appeal to you and your group and you’ll want to take into consideration the other categories.  For some guests, the theme is the most important part of their resort choice.  While the theme may be vital to your vacation, I would still strongly recommend taking into consideration dining, transportation, room quality, and pool areas.  Suffice to say, you won’t be disappointed by the top choices in this category and the resorts at the bottom of the list have something to offer as well.

Best Layout

1. Grand Floridian Resort

2. Contemporary Resort

3. Wilderness Lodge

4. Animal Kingdom Lodge

5. Polynesian Resort

6. Yacht Club

7. Beach Club

8. Boardwalk Inn

This is a difficult category to quantify for the Deluxe resorts because so much of it depends on your room location and your personal preferences.  I have the Grand Floridian in first place because the restaurants, monorail station, and check-in are all located in the centralized main building that is relatively near all of the rooms.  It’s easy to move around the resort and find what you’re looking for and none of the points of interest are far from one another.  The Contemporary Resort comes in second because rooms in the Tower are so convenient to the restaurants, check-in, and monorail station.  Guests are just a short walk and elevator ride away.  However, guests staying in the Garden Wing must walk a considerable distance to the Tower and Tower guests are relatively far from the dock and pool.  Still, it’s generally quick and easy to find what you need as you move about the resort.  In third place, the Wilderness Lodge is shaped somewhat like a large “V” with two long wings jutting out of the main building.  The good news is that the walkways are easy to traverse and air-conditioned; the bad news is that a room at the end of one of the wings means a considerable walk to get to the restaurants, check-in, and bus stop.  The wings are shorter than the Animal Kingdom Lodge’s and a slightly longer walk is better than the confusing hallways of the Epcot-area resorts.  The pools are also centrally located behind the resort along with the dock and beach areas.  In fourth place is the Animal Kingdom Lodge, which has a similar design to the Wilderness Lodge, only the wings are longer.  This can equate to a long walk to the buses and restaurants if you find yourself at the end of the wings.  Luckily, the rooms at the end of the wings generally have the best view of the savannas and the hallways are nicely air-conditioned.  Request a room on the Zebra Trail to be nearer to the pool facilities.

The Polynesian is a small resort with a centralized main building, pool, dock, and transportation stations, but the layout can be confusing due to the meandering walkways and scattered guest buildings.  It’s fairly easy to find the main building with the restaurants, check-in, and monorail station, but getting back to your room may be difficult because the buildings all look the same.  Chances are you’ll get the hang of it by the time you leave, but it may take a few trips before you figure out exactly which path to take.  The pools, dock, and beaches are all centrally located in the middle and the back of the resort which is nice and nothing is more than five or ten minutes away from anything else which cuts down on walking.  The Boardwalk Inn, Yacht Club, and Beach Club, all feature a similar layout with long winding hallways and points of interest that may be far away or at another resort entirely.  For example, the Yacht Club and Beach Club share amenities, including Stormalong Bay and a counter service.  This can mean a substantial walk to and from the pool and a particularly long walk for Yacht Club guests to get to the Beach Club’s counter service location.  The Beach and Yacht Club also share a dock, which is directly behind the Yacht Club.  This equates to a 10-15 minute walk over to the Yacht Club for guests at the Beach Club who want to use water transportation.  Finally, both the Yacht and Beach Club sit next to the beautiful Crescent Lake, but few rooms have balconies that look directly out at it.

Considering Disney’s attention to detail and careful planning, it’s a bit surprising that many of the Deluxe resorts have poor, confusing layouts. While it’s unlikely the resort’s layout will ruin your vacation, long walks from the bus to your room in the heat or rain after spending ten hours running around a theme park can make a wonderful day end on a sour note.  Pay attention to the “Best Rooms” categories of each resort to hone in on the best room locations.  While the best rooms are also usually the most expensive, there are advantages to some Standard rooms too, which is what those sections cover.  If you’re able to get one of the “best” rooms at the Yacht Club, then chances are it will be better than one of the worst rooms at the Contemporary or Grand Floridian.  For this reason, room location is even more important than overall layout, but it’s important to keep the overall layout in mind, especially when considering the bottom five choices on the list.

Best Dining

1. Grand Floridian Resort

2. Polynesian Resort

3. Animal Kingdom Lodge

4. Contemporary Resort

5. Wilderness Lodge

6. Boardwalk Inn

7. Beach Club

8. Yacht Club

Most of the Disney Deluxe resorts have at least one excellent restaurant.  It’s the secondary restaurants and counter services that may be lacking.  With the most overall choices and Victoria and Albert’s, the finest restaurant in all of Disney World, the Grand Floridian wins this category.  Citricos and Narcoossee’s are both excellent choices and 1900 Park Fare is a great character meal at breakfast.  Gasparilla Grill and Games, while not amazing, is a decent counter service that is convenient when your pocketbook is eyeing a cheaper alternative.  The Grand Floridian also serves a relaxing afternoon tea with a wide variety of drinks and snacks.  The Polynesian Resort is a close second, featuring Kona, one of the best non-signature restaurants at any of the Deluxes and ‘Ohana, a popular family style meal.  The Polynesian also offers the Spirit of Aloha Polynesian dinner show with good food and fun entertainment.  In third place is the Animal Kingdom Lodge, which features Boma, one of the best buffet meals at Disney.  You’ll find a great number of authentic African-inspired dishes as well as traditional buffet flavors.  Jiko, the resort’s signature restaurant, is also an excellent restaurant with a relaxing atmosphere and fantastic wine.  The Animal Kingdom Lodge’s counter service is also among the best at Disney and the new Sanaa restaurant at Kidani Village is a welcome addition as well.  The California Grill, located on the 15th floor of the Contemporary Resort, still features some of the best views at Disney World.  Unfortunately, the quality of the food and service has diminished in recent years.  It remains a recommended restaurant because of the fantastic view, especially during the fireworks show, and the food is above-average.  Also at the Contemporary, The Wave is a vastly underrated table service restaurant and the Contempo Café is your standard counter service – too small to meet demand, but efficient enough.  I don’t recommend Chef Mickey’s, but it is still one of the most popular character buffets and a decent choice if you’re staying at the Contemporary, don’t mind crowds and noise, and don’t have a particularly discernable palette.

Coming in fifth is the Wilderness Lodge.  Artist Point, the resort’s signature restaurant, serves great food and the service is generally good as well, but it’s lacking the flair that several of the higher rated restaurants possess.  While there’s certainly nothing wrong with it, there just isn’t anything special about it either.  Roaring Fork is the resort’s undersized counter service.  Like most of the resorts’ counter services, the seating area is inadequate, so expect to take your food elsewhere if you visit during peak times.  Whispering Canyon can be a fun restaurant, but both the service and food are inconsistent and the prices are on the higher side.  If it’s convenient or you’re visiting the Wilderness Lodge then it’s a good choice if you don’t mind the prices, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to eat here.

The bottom three resorts are all nearby each other and the idea seems to be that if you’re staying at one then you should be willing to walk to the others to fill your dining needs.  In last place is the Yacht Club, which has no counter service location.  Even people that swear off counter services all together usually visit sometime during their stay for a quick coffee or ice cream.  It also makes refillable mugs less desirable because you’ll have to walk to Stormalong Bay or the Beach Club to fill it up.  The Yacht Club’s two sit-down restaurants, the Yachtsman Steakhouse and Captain’s Grill, are both fine choices for a meal, but neither of them offers much Disney magic.  The Yachtsman is superior in service, food, and price and is comparable to the popular Le Cellier at the Canada Pavilion in Epcot.  Unlike the Yacht Club, the Beach Club offers no signature restaurants and no real “fine dining” options.  Instead, you’ll find Beaches and Cream which is a fun place for a burger or an ice cream, but the seating area is grossly inadequate and you’ll likely be looking at waits in the one hour range.  The Cape May Café is an interesting buffet, serving all-you-can-eat crab legs at dinner, and is a good choice for big eaters.  The Beach Club Marketplace is disappointing, serving only sandwiches and salads for lunch and dinner.

At the top of the Epcot-area resorts is the Boardwalk Inn, which sits on top of several restaurants.  Unfortunately, while there may be a large variety of choices, none of them are particularly good and I wouldn’t necessarily recommend any of them.  Flying Fish is the best of the bunch, but it also costs two credits on the Disney Dining Plan and most entrées are in the $40 range, which makes it considerably overpriced out of pocket.  Despite the high prices, the restaurant’s atmosphere is decidedly relaxed, which may or may not be a good thing. The best feature of the Epcot-area Deluxes is that they are near Epcot, which means you’re just a five to ten minute walk away from all of those restaurants.  The bad news is that you’ll need a Park Hopper ticket to eat there unless you plan to spend the entire day at Epcot.

Overall, the Deluxes have the best dining options of the Disney resort classes.  Even the last place Yacht Club is far superior to anything you would find at the Moderates or Values.  The unique characteristic of the Deluxes is that unless you’re staying at the Animal Kingdom Lodge, you’re close to at least two of the other Deluxe resorts and one of the major theme parks.  For example, if you’re staying at the Contemporary Resort then you’re only a monorail ride away from the Grand Floridian, Polynesian, and Magic Kingdom and only a boat ride away from the Wilderness Lodge.  If you’re staying at the Boardwalk then you’re only a walk or boat ride away from the Yacht and Beach Club as well as Epcot and the Hollywood Studios.  This gives you a lot of dining options, even if the restaurants at your particular resort don’t sound appealing.  If you’re staying at the Animal Kingdom Lodge then it’s going to be less convenient to hop to the other resorts, so you’ll want to make sure those restaurants sound appealing.

Best Transportation/Location

1. Contemporary Resort

2. Polynesian Resort

3. Boardwalk Inn

4. Yacht Club

5. Grand Floridian

6. Wilderness Lodge

7. Beach Club

8. Animal Kingdom

The Contemporary is the only resort where guests can easily walk to and from the Magic Kingdom.  It also offers boat service to the Wilderness Lodge and Fort Wilderness Cabins as well as Monorail access to the Magic Kingdom, Transportation Center, Polynesian, and Grand Floridian. Finally, the Contemporary has the best bus service of the Monorail Deluxes because it’s picked up and dropped off before the others when bus service is shared.  Coming in second is the Polynesian, which is on the monorail line, has an easily accessible bus stop, and is in walking distance to the express monorail line to Epcot.  Walking to the express monorail will save you a lot of time because you won’t have to travel around on the resort monorail and then wait for the express monorail to show up at the Ticket and Transportation Center.  The Polynesian also offers boat service to the Magic Kingdom and Grand Floridian which is handy as well.  The Boardwalk Inn is at the top of the Epcot-area resorts because it’s the closest and has its own dock that is centrally located at the back of the resort.  It’s also the closest resort within walking distance of the Hollywood Studios.  With boat access to the Swan, Dolphin, Yacht Club, Beach Club, Epcot, and Hollywood Studios, there are plenty of places to visit via boat, which is much more fun than riding a stuffy bus.  Of course, the Boardwalk Inn is also right on top of the Boardwalk area with its fun restaurants, night clubs, and street shows.  Coming in fourth is the Yacht Club, which is rated higher than the nearby Beach Club because the boat dock happens to be behind the Yacht Club.  This makes it much more convenient for guests to travel via boat to all of the same locations as at the Boardwalk Inn listed above.

Leading the bottom half of the list, the Grand Floridian is on the monorail line and has convenient boat access to the Magic Kingdom and Polynesian resort.  Why is it so low on the list then?  Unfortunately, the Grand Floridian has poor bus service, usually sharing with the far-away Wilderness Lodge which gets picked up and dropped off first.  This can mean longer than average bus rides to the Hollywood Studios and the Grand Floridian is the farthest resort away from the Animal Kingdom.  Coming in sixth is the Wilderness Lodge, which has boat access to the Magic Kingdom, but buses everywhere else.  The Wilderness Lodge often shares buses with the nearby Fort Wilderness Campground and the much less convenient Grand Floridian, which adds considerable extra time to bus rides.  It’s not in walking distance of any of the theme parks and is relatively isolated away from the rest of the action.  The Beach Club falls all the way to sixth because guests will have to walk all the way to the back of the Yacht Club for boat transportation that is shared by many other resorts and theme parks.  Like the Yacht Club and Boardwalk Inn, there is also no bus service to the front of Epcot.  Last place goes to the Animal Kingdom, which only offers bus service to all of the theme parks.  It’s also the most remote Disney resort and the furthest from all of the theme parks other than the Animal Kingdom.  You’re looking at a 45 minute drive to and from the Magic Kingdom.

Overall, the Deluxe resorts offer the most diverse transportation options of the Disney resort classes.  Both the monorail and boats offer a more fun way to get around the World and the convenience of being so close to the theme parks and other resorts is a nice bonus.

Best Rooms

1. Contemporary Resort

2. Grand Floridian Resort

3. Polynesian Resort

4. Yacht Club

5. Beach Club

6. Boardwalk Inn

7. Animal Kingdom Lodge

8. Wilderness Lodge

Disregarding price, the updated Contemporary Resort rooms are the nicest, most modern rooms at Disney World.  Some guests may still prefer the subtler elegance of the Grand Floridian’s large, well-appointed rooms.  In third place is the Polynesian Resort.  Although its rooms feel a bit dark and outdated, they are still among the largest at Disney World and feature upgraded fixtures, bathrooms, and televisions.  The Yacht and Beach Club as well as the Boardwalk Inn all have rooms that are about 380 square feet in size.  As far as the room itself is concerned, they are all similarly outfitted with the only major difference being the theme.  The Yacht Club is the most recently renovated, followed by the Beach Club and then the Boardwalk Inn.  Chances are you won’t notice much difference between the three.  Both the Animal Kingdom Lodge and Wilderness Lodge have rooms that are much smaller than the other Deluxes, at only about 340 square feet.  They are also dark and standard rooms sleep only four people, compared to five at the other Deluxes.  While the Animal Kingdom Lodge and Wilderness Lodge are considerably less expensive, the major reason behind the price difference is the smaller rooms with lower quality furnishings.

Best Pool

1. Stormalong Bay at the Beach and Yacht Club

2. Boardwalk Inn

3. Grand Floridian Resort

4. Wilderness Lodge

5. Polynesian Resort

6. Contemporary Resort

7. Animal Kingdom Lodge

Far and away, the best pool complex is Stormalong Bay, which is shared by guests of the Yacht and Beach Club.  It’s also the most heavily secured and resort guests must show their room key to receive a wristband and gain entrance. Boardwalk Inn features a spectacular slide, a fun theme, and a large pool which puts it in second place.  The Grand Floridian’s main pool, while not ornately themed, overlooks the pristine Seven Seas Lagoon and the quiet pool is the largest of its kind.  It ranks so high because there is usually plenty of room to swim and move about the water.  In fourth place, the Wilderness Lodge features a beautifully themed pool and a second quiet pool.  While the feature pool gets busy in the summer, the quiet pool usually has plenty of room.  The Polynesian would be much higher on the list, probably in second place, except it’s so popular with “pool hoppers.”  Although people staying at other resorts are expressly forbidden from swimming at the Polynesian, plenty of people still do and the resort does a poor job of keeping them out.  This makes the Polynesian’s Volcano Pool extremely busy in the warm months.  Although there is a smaller quiet pool, it’s much less fun to swim in than the Volcano Pool.  Next to last is the Contemporary Resort, which has two large pools, but little theme or decoration.  The slide is also not particularly exciting.  In last place is the Animal Kingdom Lodge, which only has one pool open to all guests (guests staying at the Kidani Village Disney Vacation Club have access to a second pool).  While it is the largest single pool in Disney World, it doesn’t make up for the convenient quiet pools at other resorts.  If your room is at the end of Kudu Trail, you’re looking at a 15+ minute walk to and from the pool, which may be a hassle.

Chances are you’ll be pleased with the pool facilities at any of the Deluxes.  Although the Animal Kingdom comes in last, the pool is still fantastic and it’s located in a beautifully themed area.  It’s just unfortunate they neglected to build a second one on the other side of the resort.

Best Disney World Deluxe Resort Hotel

1. Grand Floridian

2. Polynesian Resort

3. Beach Club

4. Wilderness Lodge

5. Contemporary Resort

6. Yacht Club

7. Animal Kingdom Lodge

8. Boardwalk Inn

The “best” Deluxe resort is difficult to quantify because of the varying price points and substantial differences between the resorts.  At the very least, I would recommend reading over the “best for” and “worst for” sections along with the “summary of key points” for each of the Deluxe resorts you are considering.  While the Animal Kingdom Lodge may be listed seventh on this list, it may be ideal for your family if you don’t mind the longer-than-average bus rides, four person limit per room, and the possibility of substantial walks to the main building and pool.  In addition, the Grand Floridian is the most expensive resort at Disney World and may not be worth the $200 extra per night over the Wilderness Lodge if your group doesn’t plan to spend much time at the resort.  Unlike the Values and Moderates, the Deluxes have more substantial differences and the top rated resorts may not be the best choice depending on your wants and needs.  Here’s as short of an explanation as I can give on the pros and cons of the various Deluxes and why they fall where they do, generally speaking.

The Grand Floridian is the best of the Deluxe resorts, with the largest rooms, easy to maneuver layout, oversized pools, finest restaurants, and quick transportation to the Magic Kingdom.  The only deterrents are its bus transportation to the other theme parks and the high cost.  While some visitors report feeling “stuffy,” the great majority of Grand Floridian guests are just like you and me.  That is, people who have diligently saved over the year(s) to afford to stay at Disney’s best.  It’s truly a beautiful resort with all of the amenities one would expect from a top resort.  On the other hand, it may only be worth the money if you plan to spend a considerable amount of time relaxing and enjoying the resort and its amenities.  The Polynesian has many of the same pros and cons as the Grand Floridian, but falls below it due to the somewhat outdated décor in the rooms, more difficulty finding what you’re looking for inside of the resort, and the overcrowded pools.  On the plus side, the Polynesian has much better transportation, including a walkway to the Ticket and Transportation Center and a more relaxing, family friendly atmosphere.

The Beach Club tops the Epcot-area resorts because of its ideal location within walking distance of Epcot, its relaxed atmosphere, superior service, Stormalong Bay, and several casual restaurants on-site.  The major downsides are its lack of balconies overlooking the lake, its shared bus and boat transportation, and a lackluster counter service.  Luckily, you can visit Stormalong Bay for a burger or walk to Epcot and visit one of their excellent counter service locations, so there really isn’t that much of a need for a counter service with more abundant options.  Of course, it would still be nice.  In fourth place is the Wilderness Lodge, which has a tranquil atmosphere, attractive price point, above-average transportation, and a fun pool area.  Although the rooms are smaller than the other Deluxes, the significantly lower price reflects it.  The Wilderness Lodge also has boat service to the Contemporary and Magic Kingdom, which easily connects guests to the other Monorail Deluxes and Epcot express monorail line.  Although it appears to be secluded, it actually isn’t that far away, so you get the benefit of being away from the hustle and bustle of the theme parks while still being close to the action.  It’s an excellent resort for guests wanting to be conveniently located near the Magic Kingdom without the additional expense of the Monorail Deluxes.

Falling to fifth place is the Contemporary Resort, mostly due to its lack of a theme and high cost for rooms outside of the Garden Wing.  While it’s true that the Contemporary Resort boasts the cheapest rooms on the monorail line, the Contemporary’s Tower rooms start at $400 which is in line with Standard rooms at the Polynesian and Grand Floridian, both of which have a superior theme.  The Contemporary’s strong points are its convenience to the Magic Kingdom and other Monorail Deluxes, boat service to the Wilderness Lodge, modern rooms, and easy to navigate layout.  If you don’t care for a lush tropical atmosphere or the opulence of the Grand Floridian, then the Contemporary may be your best choice.  I recommend either getting the cheapest room in the Garden Wing or upgrading to the Magic Kingdom View in the Tower.  There’s really no reason to spend the money to upgrade anywhere else.

In sixth place, the Yacht Club completely lacks a counter service location, has a confusing layout, shares buses and boats with many other resorts, and features a less popular theme.  While guests looking for a more upscale atmosphere may appreciate the Yacht Club, it may feel a bit stuffy to guests with younger children.  The positives are similar to the Beach Club and include the best pool complex at Disney World, an excellent location within walking distance of Epcot and many other resorts, and upgraded rooms.  If you prefer a fancy resort and don’t plan to eat any counter service meals on-site, then the Yacht Club may be your ideal resort.

The Animal Kingdom Lodge drops to seventh because of its remote location.  Unless you plan to spend considerable time on your balcony looking at the animals, you are better off staying closer to the other theme parks and visiting the Animal Kingdom to enjoy its restaurants or the public animal viewing areas.  It’s about a 35 minute drive from the Animal Kingdom Lodge to the Magic Kingdom and 25 minutes or more to Epcot and Hollywood Studios.  If you have to wait 15 minutes for the bus then you’re looking at 80-120 minutes or more on the buses, assuming you only ride to and from the theme parks once.  Depending on room location you’re also looking at considerable walks to and from the bus stop, main building, pool, and restaurants.  On the plus side, the Animal Kingdom is a beautiful resort with a striking lobby and three superb restaurants.  If you don’t mind the long drives or plan to spend a significant portion of your vacation at your resort then the Animal Kingdom may be a good choice.  There are better options for first time Disney vacationers and those who plan to spend most of their time away from the resort.

In last place, though not without its positive attributes, is the Boardwalk Inn.  While I love the exterior theme and the rooms overlooking the Boardwalk are among the most fun at Disney World, the interior leaves a lot to be desired.  The layout is particularly confusing, with long winding halls and inconvenient elevator locations.  There is also no on-site counter service and no restaurants inside of the resort.  Instead, you’ll have to exit the resort and enter the restaurants from the outside.  While there are plenty of choices, the ESPN Club, Kouzzina, and Big River Grille are nothing special and do not come highly recommended.  At a minimum of $425 per night, the rooms that overlook the Boardwalk cost about as much as a Magic Kingdom View room at the Contemporary Resort or Standard room at the Polynesian or Grand Floridian.  I would recommend visiting the Boardwalk area during your vacation, but don’t generally recommend the resort itself.  One more positive that I have not previously mentioned is the Inn’s underutilized Bellevue Lounge, which is a fantastic place to sip on a fine cocktail and enjoy an afternoon or evening.

There is a Disney Deluxe resort that will fit anyone’s needs, provided you have a budget that allows for it.  With a large pricing gap and a wide variety of strengths and weaknesses, it may take some time to research and determine which resort will best fit your group’s needs.  Hopefully this abridged guide will help.  Be sure to read up on the individual resorts that sound intriguing for even more information.  I have a detailed overview of every Disney resort, including a closer look at each of the categories listed here and suggestions on room reservations.  Good luck and happy planning.

{ 4 comments }

Best Disney World Moderate Resort Hotel

by josh on June 2, 2010

Best Disney World Moderate Resort Hotel

Quick Introduction to the Disney World Moderate Resorts

The best Moderate resort choice is not as obvious as it is with the Value resorts, unfortunately.  There are many substantial differences in resort size and layout, transportation efficiency, theme, room amenities, pool size, dining choices, and more.  You may have to make some compromises and decide what features are most important.  For example, the French Quarter has the best transportation and layout, but the worst restaurant choices and pool.  Luckily, the Moderates are all priced the same, except for the Coronado Springs which is about $5 more per night, so differences in cost won’t be a major concern.  Take a look at the following ratings to identify which Moderate is the best fit for your group and be sure to read the full review of the resorts you’re interested in to make the most informed decision.

Click the highlighted links to read the full review of any of the resorts listed or click here for all of the Moderate resort reviews on a scrollable page.

Best Theme/Landscaping

1. Caribbean Beach Resort

2. Port Orleans Riverside Resort

3. Coronado Springs Resort

4. Port Orleans French Quarter Resort

This is the toughest category because the theme that appeals to you and your group may be different than what appeals to others.  Generally, the Caribbean Beach Resort is favored because of its relaxing vibe, bright colors, and gorgeous lake setting.  The white sand beaches that line the exterior of the resort are beautiful and the plentiful hammocks and lounging areas are second to none.

Port Orleans Riverside comes in second.  Its lush landscaping, picturesque setting on the Sassagoula River, and the working 35-foot water wheel help elevate its ranking.  Alligator Bayou and Magnolia Bend, the two distinct areas that make up the Port Orleans Riverside, are visually interesting and provide two different interpretations of the Louisiana Bayou.

The Coronado Springs Resort, with its Spanish-colonial theme, is another beautiful resort that encircles the 22-acre Lago Dorado lake.  It falls into third place primarily because it is the major convention resort and many of its guests may not be at the resort for a typical Disney vacation.  Nonetheless, the atmosphere is serene and relaxing and there are plenty of areas to relax on the white sand beaches.

Port Orleans French Quarter drops to last place.  Many of its decorations appear cheap, especially in the food court and main building where New Orleans paraphernalia merely hangs from the ceiling on strings.  While Disney will tell you that they purchased “some” of the memorabilia directly from New Orleans, it still isn’t impressive.

As far as landscaping is concerned, all of the Moderate resorts are on a level well above the Value resorts and only a small step down from the Deluxes.  Chances are high that you will enjoy your surroundings no matter which Moderate resort you choose.

Best Layout

1. Port Orleans French Quarter Resort

2. Port Orleans Riverside Resort

3. Coronado Springs Resort

4. Caribbean Beach Resort

The French Quarter is the smallest Moderate resort, both in terms of rooms and overall square acreage.  This means that your room won’t be more than a five minute walk away from the food court, bus stop, pool, main building, or boat dock.  This is a huge advantage, especially in times of suffocating heat or torrential downpour.  It also makes it much more convenient to refill a mug or get a snack.  The rest of the Moderate resorts are large and spread out and it’s more important to take heed of the “best rooms” section of the full resort reviews and consider paying extra for a “Preferred” location.

Port Orleans Riverside is slightly ahead of the other two due to the fact that most of the rooms are close to something of interest, whether it be the feature pool, main building, or food court.  Unlike the Coronado and Caribbean, there isn’t a gigantic lake in the middle of the Port Orleans Riverside that you have to maneuver around.

It’s as much as a mile from the main building to the most remote rooms at the Coronado and Caribbean Beach resorts, which can be a significant hassle with children or those who have trouble walking.  Luckily, the Caribbean Beach has an internal shuttle that travels around the resort’s exterior and employees of the Coronado Springs will drive you around the resort in golf carts if necessary.  While both of those methods may be convenient once you board them, it’s not always easy to hunt down interior transportation.  The Caribbean Beach Resort is even more sprawling than the Coronado Springs which is why the Caribbean falls to last place.

Best Dining

1. Port Orleans Riverside Resort

2. Coronado Springs Resort

3. Caribbean Beach Resort

4. Port Orleans French Quarter Resort

None of the Moderates have quick service or full service restaurants worth visiting if you’re not staying at the resort.  There just isn’t anything particularly special about any of them, although you might consider the Pepper Market if you’re on the Disney Dining Plan due to its high cost.  With that said, the Port Orleans Riverside has the best quick service location and Boatwright’s, the best table service restaurant.  The Riverside Mill, the Riverside’s quick service, is actually better than most of the Deluxes.  If you’re planning to eat many of your meals at the resort and want to stay at a Moderate then the Riverside is your best bet.

Coronado Springs Resort comes in second, but has some serious caveats.  First, you’ll probably want to be on the Disney Dining Plan if you plan to eat more than two meals at the Coronado.  The Pepper Market Grill is one of the most expensive quick service locations and the Maya Grill is an overpriced table service restaurant.  Read the full Coronado review for more information about these restaurants.

The Caribbean Beach Resort features a quick service location by the name of Old Port Royale and Shutters, the dinner-only Caribbean themed full service restaurant.  While the food at Old Port Royale is good and the setting is pleasant, the space is too small to handle the amount of people that fill it during peak times.  Shutters is decent, especially if you have low standards, but the menu is limited to just a handful of the usual entrées and the setting is nothing special.  If you’re not in the mood to leave the resort or can’t find another restaurant to visit then it will do the job, but this is far from a destination restaurant.

Finally, Port Orleans French Quarter drops to last because it doesn’t have a full service restaurant.  Guests staying at the French Quarter are invited to walk or bus over to Boatwright’s at the Riverside.  It’s an additional hassle and it’s unfortunate that the small number of guests staying at the French Quarter can’t support their own restaurant.  The French Quarter’s quick service location is also lacking, with a small capacity and a limited selection of food.  It will suffice if you’re not in the mood to travel elsewhere, but don’t expect to be impressed by the quality, prices, or selection.

All in all, the full service restaurants at the Moderate resorts are a bit disappointing, considering the excellent restaurants found at the Deluxe resorts.  Chances are that you’ll have a decent to above average meal, but you’re generally better off seeking food at one of the recommended restaurants and counter services throughout Disney World.

Best Transportation

1. Port Orleans French Quarter Resort

2. Port Orleans Riverside Resort

3. Coronado Springs Resort

4. Caribbean Beach Resort

Both Port Orleans resorts, the French Quarter and Riverside, generally share transportation.  The French Quarter has the advantage because it is picked up and dropped off first for all destinations other than Downtown Disney.  This usually guarantees French Quarter guests a seat on the bus and the French Quarter only has one bus stop, which makes it easy to navigate to the correct line.

Despite being picked up and dropped off after the French Quarter, the Port Orleans Riverside benefits from having above-average bus service.  Waits are usually shorter at both Port Orleans resorts than they would be at the other Moderates.  The Port Orleans Moderates are also somewhat centrally located, which means relatively short bus rides.  Finally, the Port Orleans resorts both have a dock with boat service to Downtown Disney.  The ride is scenic and it is the preferred transportation method when heading Downtown.

Both the Coronado Springs Resort and Caribbean Beach Resort have a lot of bus stops.  If you get on at one of the early stops, you’ll be more likely to get a seat (rather than stand), but you’ll also have to wait for the bus to circle the resort as it stops at the other six-or-so stops.  Getting on at the final stop will lessen your transit time on the way to the Park, but will also result in you standing more often than not.  On the return trip, you’ll also have to wait for the bus to stop and let off guests at all the preceding stops as well.

The Coronado Springs Resort comes in third because the buses are usually empty if the resort is full of conventioneers who aren’t visiting the theme parks.  The problem is that the conventioneers will probably go to the Parks at least one day and Disney isn’t that quick in upping the amount of buses necessary to service all the additional riders.  This can lead to long waits.

The Caribbean Beach has the worst transportation of the bunch.  Waits tend to be the longest of the Moderates and it also takes the longest for the buses to circle the resort to pick up and drop off guests.

Best Rooms

1. Coronado Springs Resort

2. Port Orleans French Quarter

3. Caribbean Beach Resort

4. Port Orleans Riverside

The Coronado Springs Resort is the only Moderate to have a wood divider between the vanity area and the sleeping area, which keeps much more of the light and noise out compared to the cloth divider found at the other Moderates.  It’s also one of the two Moderate resorts that offers comfortable queen-size beds, which makes it easier to sleep four people.  Coronado Springs is also recently refurbished, with new furniture, linens, carpets, and flat-screen televisions.  Of the Moderates, the Coronado’s rooms are the best appointed, though the Port Orleans French Quarter rooms are very nicely appointed as well.

Port Orleans French Quarter underwent a serious refurbishment in early 2011.  Resort rooms now feature two queen-size beds, flat-screen televisions, and all new furniture.  The rooms are not quite as nice as Coronado Springs, particularly because of the lack of a door separating the sleeping area and bathroom, but they are still nicer than the rooms found at Caribbean Beach Resort.

The Caribbean Beach is also recently refurbished with a subtle Finding Nemo theme in most of its rooms and fantastically themed (and much more expensive) Pirates of the Caribbean rooms.  Rooms are bright and the renovation brought new furnishings and televisions.  However, you won’t find queen-size beds like you the French Quarter and Coronado Springs offer.

Port Orleans Riverside is the only Moderate Resort that can officially sleep five people in the Alligator Bayou section, thanks to the addition of the trundle bed.  While the trundle bed is designed to sleep a small child under the age of nine or so, it may offer a cheaper alternative to one of the family suites.  Unfortunately, Port Orleans Riverside is the only Moderate that has not undergone a refurbishment.  That will change in June 2011 when the rooms will be refurbished.  If you trip isn’t until July or later, you have a chance of getting one of the refurbished rooms.  Be sure to request one when you book.  The refurbishment should be completed by December 2011.

Generally, the Coronado Springs’ rooms are kept in the best shape in order to please convention guests.  All Moderate guest rooms measure 314 square feet (yes, even the Caribbean Beach’s which are sometimes listed at 340 square feet), so you won’t find any advantages in square footage.

Best Pool

1. Coronado Springs Resort

2. Caribbean Beach Resort

3. Port Orleans Riverside

4. Port Orleans French Quarter

Featuring a 50-foot tall Mayan Temple, 123-foot long water slide, and 272,000 gallons of water, the Coronado Springs boasts an impressive feature pool in the form of The Dig Site.  Each of the Coronado’s three sections has a convenient quiet pool as well.

The Caribbean Beach’s feature pool, designed to look like the famous Fuentes del Morro Fort, is a close second.  There is also a quiet pool in each of the Caribbean Beach’s sections – six in total.

The Port Orleans Riverside has decent pools, but they’re a significant step down from the top two choices.  The feature pool at the Riverside is 158,000 gallons, more than 100,000 smaller than The Dig Site, and features a 95-foot slide.  There are also five quiet pools located throughout the resort.

Coming in last is the Port Orleans French Quarter, which only has one swimming pool and one small hot tub.  Guests staying at the French Quarter are welcome to use the pools at the Port Orleans Riverside, but it isn’t ideal to have to walk the ten or so minutes both ways to enjoy a good swim.

Best Disney World Moderate Resort Overall

1. Port Orleans French Quarter Resort

2. Port Orleans Riverside Resort

3. Coronado Springs Resort

4. Caribbean Beach Resort

Considering that the Port Orleans French Quarter comes in dead last in three of the six categories, this may seem like a surprising conclusion.  Let me explain.  Arguably, the two most important categories are transportation and layout.  The bottom line is that the French Quarter will allow you to spend more time where you want to be – the theme parks.  First, the French Quarter is the smallest of the Moderates, which means rooms are close to points of interest.  If you’re placed in the Ranchos section at the Coronado Springs or Jamaica building at the Caribbean Beach, you can expect to have to walk about one mile each way from your room to the food court, main building, or feature pool.  That’s at least a 20 minute walk, round-trip.  This makes it difficult to refill a refillable mug, get a quick bite to eat, ask the front desk a question in person, or transport your luggage after check-in.  At the French Quarter, you’re only a few minutes away from everything.

Second, transportation is key.  You don’t want to spend any more time on Disney buses than you have to and the French Quarter is by far the best in the transportation category.  During peak times, the French Quarter will have dedicated bus transportation and won’t have to share with the Riverside, another plus.  Considering the amount of walking you’ll be doing or have already done, it’s nice to be able to sit down and relax on the bus rather than have to hold on to a bar and hope the bus doesn’t make a tight turn or go over a bump.  The scenic boat ride to Downtown Disney is also a nice bonus.

The major downsides to the French Quarter are its pool and dining options.  You’re not necessarily missing much in the dining category, considering none of the Moderate resorts’ table service restaurants are particularly good, but it’s always nice to have the option of a convenient and relaxing full service meal.  Luckily, the Riverside is just a few minutes away and offers the best table service at any of the Moderates.

Once the Riverside’s refurbishment is completed, all of the Disney Moderate resorts will have similarly high quality rooms.  The Caribbean Beach will still lag behind because of its beds, but it still may be the best choice if you’re looking for serene surroundings or want to upgrade to a Pirate room.  The pool is also a lot of fun and some people enjoy the spread out nature of the resort.

Unfortunately, the French Quarter may not always be the best choice for your group.  If swimming is important, you’re on the Disney Dining Plan, and you plan to eat some of your meals at the resort, then the Coronado Springs Resort may be the best choice in that situation.  If you have five people in your group, don’t want to book two rooms, and want to stay in a relatively inexpensive room, then the Port Orleans Riverside may be your only option.  You’ll have to look over the ratings and reviews and decide which resort features are the most important.

{ 13 comments }

Best Disney World Value Resort Hotel

by josh on June 2, 2010

Quick Introduction to the Disney World Value Resorts

The differences between the Disney World Value resorts are more subtle than they are with the Moderates or Deluxes.  Other than the Family Suites at the All-Star Music, all Value rooms are 260 square feet and feature similar furniture, beds, bathrooms, amenities, pools, and service.  The pricing is also identical at all four Value resorts every date throughout the year, although the Pop Century is located in a different county and has a tax rate one percent lower than the All-Stars.  Even the themes and decorations are similar.  The major differences lie in the quality of bus service, the size and layout of the resort, whether or not the rooms have been refurbished recently, and counter service seating availability and quality.  Although these differences may not make a light and day difference in the overall quality of your vacation, you’ll want to consider each of the following categories in your final resort decision.  Luckily, the best Value resort is a clear choice.

Click the highlighted links to read the full review of any of the resorts listed or click here for all of the Value resort reviews on a scrollable page.

Best Theme/Landscaping

1. All-Star Movies

2. Pop Century

3. All-Star Sports/All-Star Music

All of the Value resorts feature a similar theme – bright colors, oversized iconic sculptures, and basic landscaping.  The All-Star Movies comes in first place because it’s the most “Disney” of all the resorts at Disney World.  With a 50 foot tall Buzz Lightyear, 30 foot tall Woody, and other icons from famous Disney franchises, visitors are immersed in Disney culture from the second they set foot at the resort.  Pop Century also feature sculptures of classic Disney characters, although there are less of them than at the Movies, and comes in second.  You’ll also see many sculptures based on themes from popular culture throughout the 20th century.  All-Star Sports and All-Star Music are tied for third because they are basically the same, except one has a sports theme and the other has a music theme.  The overall look of all the Value resorts is similar, so you may want to take into account which theme is most appealing to your group.

Best Layout

1. Pop Century

2. All-Star Sports/All-Star Movies/All-Star Music

The Pop Century has the best layout, with the shortest walks between any two landmarks.  Even the furthest rooms from the main building and bus stop are only a five minute walk away, compared to ten or more at any of the All-Stars.  The other three Values are a toss-up, even though the layouts are slightly different.  If you want to be close to the main building at the All-Stars, you’ll be paying $15 more per night for a Preferred room.  While Preferred rooms are available at the Pop Century, it’s not usually necessary to book one unless you want to be right on top of the pool.  For the best rooms at each of the resorts make sure to read the “Best Rooms” section in the full review.

Best Dining

1. Pop Century

2. All-Star Movies/Music/Sports

All of the Value resorts offer only one food court and no full service sit-down restaurants.  Pop Century’s food court is the largest and has the greatest variety of options.  Although Pop Century also has the greatest number of guests, the food court is usually big enough to handle the demand.  The food at the Pop Century is generally better tasting and higher quality than you’ll find at the All-Stars as well, making the Pop Century food court the best of the bunch.  The flatbread pizzas and “Mom’s Night Out” TV Dinner platters are both excellent.  The All-Star resorts all have similar food court sizes, menus, and service.  While the food and selection are decent, don’t expect to be wowed by any of the offerings.  It’s always best to avoid popular dining times, especially around 8-9am for breakfast.  Expect large crowds, long lines, and few available tables during peak hours at any of the food courts.

Best Transportation

1. Pop Century

2. All-Star Sports

3. All-Star Music

4. All-Star Movies

Pop-Century does not share bus service with any other resort, which elevates it to first place.  This means that you won’t have to wait on the bus while it travels to other resorts to pick up additional guests and the bus won’t be full from previous pickups.  Occasionally, especially during off-peak times, the three All-Star resorts will share buses.  All-Star Sports is the first stop both on the way to the theme park and on the way back from the theme park.  This usually guarantees that people staying at Sports will get a seat even when buses are shared.  Sports’ guests won’t have to wait the five to ten minutes it takes to unload guests from the other resorts on the way back either.  Music is the second stop and Movies is the third stop, which puts them in third and fourth place respectively.  If buses are shared, Movies’ guests are usually required to stand and will have to wait for guests from Sports and Music to unload before returning to their resort.

Best Rooms

1. Pop Century

2. All-Star Music

3. All-Star Sports

4. All-Star Movies

Standard and Preferred rooms at all of the Value resorts are the same size – 260 feet.  The difference is that the Pop Century is the most recently refurbished, which means newer carpet, furniture, beds, bathrooms, and upgraded flat-screen televisions.  Both the All-Star Music and Sports are recently refurbished also, but Music wins out because it’s the only Value resort that offers Family Suites (at a cost of a little more than two rooms, per night).  Otherwise, the furnishings of the regular rooms are similar at the Sports and Music and you’re just as likely to get a “good” room at either.  All-Star Movies has not been refurbished, which means the furniture, carpets, etc. may show signs of wear and the televisions have not been upgraded.

Best Pool

1. All-Star Music

2. All-Star Sports/Movies

3. Pop Century

Technically, any guest staying at one of the All-Star resorts can use the pool facilities of any of the other All-Star resorts.  That means someone staying at the All-Star Sports is more than welcome to use the pool at All-Star Movies or All-Star Music.  In practice, it’s rare that anyone would do that, other than to enjoy the activities at the All-Star Music.  It would be like walking two streets over to use the pool at someone else’s house that is exactly the same as the pool you have in your own backyard.  Anyway, All-Star Music has the best pool facilities because they have scheduled pool games and activities throughout the day.  Dance parties, pool basketball, and trivia are all common activities that usually start around 2pm and go through 9pm.  At 9pm, the All-Star Music shows a movie by the pool that is projected onto a large inflatable screen.  They’re currently showing Up, The Princess and the Frog, and Toy Story 2, so the movies are actually something people might be interested in watching.  Enjoying the movie is a nice way to wind down at the end of the evening and guests from either Sports or Movies can walk over and enjoy the films.  All-Star Sports and Movies have nearly identical pool setups to the All-Star Music, but lack the activities.  The Pop Century comes in last because it doesn’t offer evening movies or scheduled pool activities.  While Pop adds a third pool, its feature pool isn’t any larger than the All-Stars.  None of the Value resort pools have water slides or any other added bonuses.  They are little more than “just a huge pool.”

Best Disney World Value Resort Overall

1. Pop Century

2. All-Star Music

3. All-Star Sports

4. All-Star Movies

With its dedicated transportation, newly refurbished rooms, relatively small footprint, and food court with a large variety of quality food, Pop Century is the clear winner of best overall Value resort.  Although its pool is nothing to write home about, none of the other Value resorts are much better.  All-Star Music finishes in front of the other All-Star resorts because it is the only Value to offer Family Suites and its pool has the best activities and the evening movie.  Music has also been refurbished recently, so the quality of the rooms is higher than All-Star Movies.  All-Star Sports comes in third place, slightly behind All-Star Music because it lacks the suites and pool activities.  Sports does have the distinction of being the first stop on the bus route which is an advantage that puts it ahead of Movies.  Despite having the best theme, All-Star Movies falls into last place because it has not undergone a refurbishment and is the last stop on the bus route.  Although it’s fun to be surrounded by Disney icons, it doesn’t make up for the shabby furnishings and the fact that you’ll probably be standing on most bus rides.  If you’re planning to stay at a Value, take a long look at the Pop Century.

{ 4 comments }